Notation Software Users Forum  


Go Back   Notation Software Users Forum > Technical area > Suggestions and feature requests

Suggestions and feature requests Make suggestions for improving any aspect of any Notation Software product, or for new features.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 10-13-2016, 03:11 PM
Sherry C's Avatar
Sherry C Sherry C is offline
Product Manager
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Bad Axe, MI, USA (The Tip of the Thumb of Michigan)
Posts: 2,556
Default Interest survey for including a scanning/OCR feature in Notation Composer -reply here

Hello friends,

We are currently exploring many different paths for future development. One feature that has been requested in the past is the capability to scan sheet music or read electronic files (eg. PDF or image files) and have that sheet music entered as a .not song file in Notation Composer.

Since a feature like this obviously takes development effort as well as licensing costs from third party developers who create and maintain the software for such a feature, we would like to find out
  1. if you are interested in such a feature and
  2. how much you would be willing to pay for such a feature.

Please keep in mind that the current field for such software ranges from about $60 usd for stand-alone scanner/reader software that will read up to 12 staves per page for a piano score (does not do multiple instruments) and exports a MIDI file (ie. just the notes) to about $250 for stand-alone software that will read orchestral scores and export MusicXML (ie, notes for multiple instruments and annotations.)

Thanks for your input here - we appreciate feedback from our musicians to help us determine what really matters to you

Best regards,
Your Notation Software Team
__________________
Music is to the soul like water is to green growing things.
__________________________________
http://www.beanfieldcastle.net/music.html
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 10-14-2016, 02:55 AM
rrayner rrayner is offline
Moderator
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 897
Default Re: Interest survey for including a scanning/OCR feature in Notation Composer -reply

This seems an easy answer. If I look on Amazon for the other leaders in music notation software, I see:

Finale 2014 - $470
Sibelius 8 Professional - $504
Neuratron PhotoScore Ultimate 8 - $229.99
Notation Composer - $98.99

Finale and Sibelius do not have the feature you are talking about, unless I am missing by not digging deeply into the current releases. Neuratron is somewhat capable of doing what you are proposing (which I think would be wonderful), but if you want to easily and freely modify Neuratron's output, you need to export it to Sibelius to massage the content. Pretty expensive, and from personal experience, I have tried scanning both hand-written scores and professionally printed sheet music, and the output STILL needs a lot of massaging to make the music playable. I have had extended experience with that scenario: Neuratron to Sibelius to Notation Composer (via midi export) -- a tedious task and not very complete.

Neuratron to Notation Composer, skipping Sibelius, has not been very effective either. There is really no good software to do what you propose, unless I am living under a rock (which could be -- I would be happy to find out about something new I haven't heard about).

I own all four software products, even though I am not terribly fluent in the non-Composer apps. I have found Composer to be hands-down the best notation software out there. How much would I be willing to pay above the current Composer price? There is a large gap between less than $100 and the prices of the other apps, particularly if you want to include the Neuratron piece. In the $400 range, it would be very attractive, assuming the score-scanning capability, but I am assuming that you would like to target the $200 range.

Ralph Rayner

Last edited by rrayner; 10-14-2016 at 02:18 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 10-14-2016, 03:22 PM
dj dj is offline
Moderator
 
Join Date: Jan 1970
Location: Balderson, Ontario, Canada, 100 kms (60 miles) from Ottawa
Posts: 799
Default Re: Interest survey for including a scanning/OCR feature in Notation Composer -reply

My 2/100ths of a dollar.

Are you talking about re-pricing Composer? If so, I'm not sure that the average user would have enough need for the scanning feature to make up the price break.

I have an ancient version of the Sharp Eye scanning software that I've used, like, twice. I see that it's $163 US at the moment. I have used it to create midis, then brought them into Composer. As Ralph says, that then takes a lot of massaging to make it work.

Having said that I don't use it, I realize that I could have made very extensive use of it last spring when I transcribed a couple of hundred pages from sheet music. I just never thought of it and played it manually into Composer. On the other hand, that sheet music was often very old (19th century) and scanning software probably wouldn't have been very effective with it.

I wonder whether some deal with a scanning software company, such as Visiv (Sharp Eye) that would allow direct import into Composer from their program might be a better solution than an incorporated scanning feature.

Just some thoughts.

David
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 10-16-2016, 10:16 AM
Reinhold H. Reinhold H. is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Jan 1970
Location: Utting am Ammersee, Germany
Posts: 584
Default Re: Interest survey for including a scanning/OCR feature in Notation Composer -reply

Thanks for the comments so far.

Let me add here how the concept will look like and what corner stones need to be met:
  • Definitely, we cannot enhance our prices for Composer because of a scanning feature
  • Secondly, we cannot develop a scanning feature by our own
The concept would be to use Visiv's scanning engine which is the same as the scanning engine of SharpEye.
MusicXML import is planned to be one of the core features in the next release (just want to mention that it is "planned" and not yet confirmed ). So the interface from the scanning engine to Composer would be MusicXML. MusicXML offers a far wider feature range than a MIDI export/import. The MusicXML export of Visiv is pretty OK from what I have tested so far.

The scanning engine would be part of any Composer package including the trial version. The scanning engine will expire after 30 days. If the user is convinced of the OCR scanning feature he/she can purchase a scanning license. This license will be loaded by Composer without a re-installation and the scanning feature is activated

Visiv's scanning engine only imports a 1-bit bmp format (just black and white). The feature would be that any other format like pdf, jpg etc. can be used. The integration would be as such that opening a pdf, jpg etc. would be possible and all other converions happen in the background.

Clearly, the notation score can only be as good as the scanning enging of SharpEye. Any adjustments due to a bad scanning need to be made in Composer.

Our questionare is about "what a customer would be willing to pay for this additional scanning feature".
This question is crucial to us due to the Visiv's license prices because this is the only royalty costs which we have so far.

Reinhold
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 10-17-2016, 03:32 PM
rrayner rrayner is offline
Moderator
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 897
Default Re: Interest survey for including a scanning/OCR feature in Notation Composer -reply

Okay, Reinhold, interesting expansion concept. I like it. Why raise the price Composer for folks who wouldn't be using the scan feature. Brilliant!

So, now that you have shed a little more light on your approach, let me revise my views. The current Amazon price for Neuratron PhotoScore Ultimate 8 is $229.99, which is misleading, because from what I know, you also have to have Sibelius in order to get any kind of flexible editing of the scanned music.

So, if you add the $504 cost of Sibelius, you would have to pay $733.99 to get an almost workable capture -- for folks who would like the scan feature in Composer, that gives you a very wide margin between your Composer cost of $98.99 and Photoscore/Sibelius cost of $733.99.

As far as I am concerned, the $229.99 I paid for Photoscore is NOT worth it. I use it very little. I have some simple lead sheets that I will try again on, just to see if more frequent use makes me more proficient with it.

I hope this helps.

Ralph Rayner
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 10-18-2016, 06:30 AM
Reinhold H. Reinhold H. is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Jan 1970
Location: Utting am Ammersee, Germany
Posts: 584
Default Re: Interest survey for including a scanning/OCR feature in Notation Composer -reply

Ralph, thanks for your comments.

The scanning quality of the concept would be exactly the same as the scanning quality of SharpEye 2 which uses the Liszt OCR scanning engine.
The technical concept basically is to export a MusicXML file by the Liszt OCR engine and import this MusicXML file into Composer.

There is a long thread about the best scanning OCR engine in the forum of the MuseScore folks. Unfortunately (or fortunately ) it is in German language where people contributed who did intensive testing and validations. Please find the thread here. SharpEye sounds OK and the testing that I did was OK, too for the music sheet that I used. I can recommend to try the SharpEye 2 trial version which you can download from the Visiv page. If somebody tries it, just compare the scanned score to your original music sheet and let us know what you think about the scanned quality.

From a technical platform perspective the beauty using the Liszt OCR engine is that we can perfectly use it across all platfroms which we support from Windows XP to Windows 10, Mac and Linux.

Reinhold
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Interest survey for including a scanning/OCR feature in Notation Composer Sherry C Announcements 0 10-12-2016 08:53 PM
Tutorial videos for Notation Software products Sherry C Tutorial Videos 0 03-16-2011 06:45 PM
Invitation to beta test prerelease of Composer 21 Mark Walsen (markwa) Announcements 0 04-13-2007 06:24 PM


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:25 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Notation Software Germany GmbH www.notation.com/Imprint.php