Thread: HELP
View Single Post
  #10  
Old 12-07-2005, 06:31 AM
M G Jacobs (mgj32)
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Hi Mark and David, The list

Hi Mark and David,

The list you found is helpful, David. I've looked for one that put everything in the same place, for quite a while. Nice find.

quote: It's on the to-do list to add an instrument pitch range reference in MidiNotate, as well as validation (to make sure a note is within the natural range for an instrument).

This would be great. But I beg you to include a range of instruments other than those considered more or less standard, such as trumpets in C and D, the glockenspiel, viola d'amore, etc.

Also, I can see a potential problem with the fact that it is the range, sometimes referred to as "comfortable", that is often given for an instrument, ignoring the fact that a good player can achieve notes beyond that range. For example, while the violin may reach B7 in a list, an orchestral calibre player will be able to handle up to perhaps a G8. C8 is usually given as the top flute note, but even I have made the D8 and some players can get the E8.

best,
mgj
Reply With Quote